Katie (fizz) wrote in lion_lamb,
Katie
fizz
lion_lamb

  • Mood:

Bella/Edward vs Bella/Jake

I will just point out before I even begin that I am Team Edward.

There are so many valid points for both ships and I can see why people chose the ship they do
BUT
Jacob didn't imprint on Bella so therefore even though he may love her *now* when he imprints on someone else he'll forget about Bella and become obsessed with his imprinted person (lol I don't know what to call someone who's been imprinted on!) This unfortunatley means that Bella will be on her own because I can't see her wanting to be with anyone mortal after being fought over by a vampire and a werewolf. I mean mortal in this case is kinda boring in comparison (think Mike or Tyler).
If she passes up Edward for Jake and then he turns and imprints on someone else then she'll be alone and she'll be too old in her opinion to be turned into a vampire because she'll look too old in comparision to Edward.

Did anyone else notice this? I mean everyone's set against each other and saying "But Edward's got this" or "Jake's got that" but didn't anyone notice that Jake/Bella isn't technically possible considering the whole Jake having yet to imprint? I mean Sam broke up with his girlfriend for Emily...who says the same thing won't happen to Jake and Bella if that's the way the story goes?

Sorry, little rant/ramble - just curious about what other Twilight fans think?

Everyone is entitled to their own POV and I don't mean to offend anyone.

x-posted (sorry if you end up reading it twice)

I ended up writing a whole essay on it here
Tags: discussion: book
Subscribe

  • discussion post - New Moon

    What made me think about this discussion post is the cover of New Moon Graphic Novel Part 1 and 2 put together: And kind of my comment…

  • Book Nostalgia

    image found via twilightdreamteam "When life offers a dream so far beyond any of your expectations, it's not reasonable to grieve…

  • Stephenie Meyer about the end of Twilight plus mini discussion

    She will miss seeing Rob and Kristen in love—on the silver screen. The final Twilight film, Breaking Dawn Part 2, hits theaters Nov. 16,…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Comments allowed for members only

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 28 comments
Previous
← Ctrl ← Alt
Next
Ctrl → Alt →
Previous
← Ctrl ← Alt
Next
Ctrl → Alt →

  • discussion post - New Moon

    What made me think about this discussion post is the cover of New Moon Graphic Novel Part 1 and 2 put together: And kind of my comment…

  • Book Nostalgia

    image found via twilightdreamteam "When life offers a dream so far beyond any of your expectations, it's not reasonable to grieve…

  • Stephenie Meyer about the end of Twilight plus mini discussion

    She will miss seeing Rob and Kristen in love—on the silver screen. The final Twilight film, Breaking Dawn Part 2, hits theaters Nov. 16,…